Accurately determine the attack surface for the application assign risk to the various threats drive the vulnerability mitigation process it is widely considered to be the one best method of improving the security of software. Threat modeling is a form of risk assessment that models aspects of the attack and defense sides of a particular logical entity, such as a piece of data, an. Jul 10, 2018 where program scope is largely it centric, threat modeling and vulnerability assessment may lead the way. The pasta threat modeling methodology combines an attacker centric perspective on potential threats with risk and impact analysis. A is a riskcentric threat modeling framework developed in 2012 by tony ucedavelez. A realworld wireless railway temperature monitoring system is used as a case study to validate the proposed approach.
How to improve your risk assessments with attackercentric. Cyber threat modeling can motivate the selection of threat events or threat scenarios used to evaluate and compare the capabilities of technologies, products, services. Dec 29, 2017 the threat modeling approach to security risk assessment is one way to find out. Draft special publication 800154, guide to datacentric system. This publication examines datacentric system threat modeling, which is threat modeling that is focused on protecting particular types of data within systems. Vast vast is an acronym for visual, agile, and simple threat modelling. Iriusrisk is a threat modeling tool with an adaptive questionnaire driven by an expert system which guides the user through straight forward questions about the technical architecture, the planned features and security context of the application. Throughout this book and specifically for the execution of pasta as risk centric threat modeling process, we use standard definitions for threats, attacks, and vulnerabilities such as the ones documented in the various national institute of standards and technologies nist standards and guidelines and sps special publications. Towards a systematic threat modeling approach for cyberphysical systems. National institute of standards and technology has its own data centric threat modeling methodology, which consists of four steps. Conceptually, a threat modeling practice flows from a methodology.
To prevent threats from taking advantage of system flaws, administrators can use threat modeling methods to inform defensive measures. Security analyst, senior cybersecurity threat modeling job at. Microsoft threat modeling tool 2016 is a tool that helps in finding threats in the design phase of software projects. Nist sp 800154 national institute of standards and technology on.
Towards a systematic threat modeling approach for cyberphysical systems goncalo martins 1, sajal bhatia, xenofon koutsoukos, keith stouffer 2, cheeyee tang, and richard candell2 1institute for software integrated systems isis, department of electrical engineering and computer science vanderbilt university, nashville, tennessee, usa. Pasta risk centric objectives risk centric has the objective of mitigating what matters evidence based threat modeling harvest threat intel to support threat motives leverage threat data to support prior threat patterns risk based approach focuses a lot on probability of attacks, threat. The threat model is composed of a system model representing the physical and network infrastructure layout, as well as a component model illustrating component specific threats. Recent years have witnessed the emergence of cloudhosted botnets along software defined networking sdn enhanced edge computing. Microsoft security development lifecycle threat modelling. Cyber threat modeling can focus activities by cyber defenders, including threat hunting searching for indicators or evidence of adversary activities, continuous monitoring and security assessment, and devops rapid development and operational deployment of defense tools, on specific types of threat. Threat modeling and risk management is the focus of chapter 5.
Development process, standards, and tools reuse of threat vulnerability information the organization requires the developer of the information system, system component, or information system service to use threat modeling and vulnerability analyses from similar systems, components, or services to inform the current development process. A system can be a software feature, a vendor, a business process, an asset, or anything else that required analysis. By using threat modeling to identify threats, vulnerabilities and mitigations at design time, the system develop ment team will be able to implement application security as part of the design process. Stride is a popular system centric threat modeling technique used to elicit threats in systems and the software development lifecycle sdl along the dimensions or mnemonics of spoofing, tampering, repudiation, information disclosure, denialofservice and elevation of privilege. Performing threat modeling on cyberphysical systems with a variety of stakeholders can help catch threats across a wide spectrum of threat types.
For the includes no dirt model no dirt, we needed two layers of abstraction in order to scale the threat modeling process. However, on a practical level, threat modeling methodologies vary in quality, consistency, and value received for the resources invested. Threat modeling definition threat modeling is a structured process through which it pros can identify potential security threats and vulnerabilities, quantify the seriousness of each, and prioritize techniques to mitigate attack and protect it resources. A good example of why threat modeling is needed is located at ma tte rs.
Chapter 6 and chapter 7 examine process for attack simulation and threat analysis pasta. Yi cheng, julia deng, jason li, scott deloach, anoop singhal, xinming ou. Threat modeling overview threat modeling is a process that helps the architecture team. Cvss was developed by nist and is maintained by the forum of. Threat modeling is most often applied to software applications, but it can be used for operating systems and devices with equal effectiveness. Software centric threat modeling, also referred to as systemcentric, designcentric or. Draft sp 800154 provides information on the basics of datacentric system threat modeling so that organizations can use it as part of their risk. Threat modeling is a process by which potential threats, such as structural vulnerabilities or the absence of appropriate safeguards, can be identified, enumerated, and mitigations can be prioritized. The seven performance steps to managing risk, the nist way. Every approach to risk management, cyberoriented, operational, it, financial, and so on covers the core basics nist describes as identify, protect, detect, respond, and recover. Nist requests public comments on draft special publication sp 800154, guide to data centric system threat modeling. First, we abstracted the model to be system centric.
How to improve your risk assessments with attacker centric threat modeling abstract. During the workshop, nist will present a summary of existing and ongoing work related to data classification, data security, data centric threat modeling, and zerotrust architecture. The threats identified in the system are subsequently mitigated using national institute of standards and technology nist standards. Ideally, threat modeling is applied as soon as an architecture has been established. Also, the risk and business impact analysis of the method elevates threat modeling from a software development only exercise to a strategic business exercise by involving key. Pdf towards a systematic threat modeling approach for. This book is a good book for anyone in software design and development to understand how to write secure. Nist announce the release of draft special publication 800154. Stride to a secure smart grid in a hybrid cloud springerlink. Aug 12, 2019 from a theoretical perspective, each threat modeling technique and methodology provides security teams and organizations with the means to identify threats and may be seen on equal footing. Identify and characterize the system and data of interest. In a softwarecentric model, the team considers an application or a feature and analyzes the data flows and trust boundaries to identify how they could be abused or misused. Data centric system threat modeling is a form of risk assessment that models aspects of the attack and defense sides for selected data within a system.
Cisos and risk analysts alike often get caught up in checking boxes on a list of control objectives in order to satisfy compliance and regulatory requirements. The completed threat model is used to build a risk model on the basis of asset, roles, actions, and calculated risk exposure. The purpose of threat modeling is to provide defenders with a systematic analysis of what controls or defenses need to be included, given the nature of the system, the probable attackers profile, the most likely attack. The microsoft threat modeling tool 2016 will be endoflife on october 1st 2019. Towards a systematic threat modeling approach for cyber.
Second, we abstracted the analysis to be primarily controls focused rather than brainstorming focused. In this paper, we conduct comprehensive threat modeling exercises based on two representative cloud infrastructures using several popular threat modeling methods, including attack surface, attack trees, attack graphs, and security metrics based on attack trees and attack graphs, respectively. Murugiah souppaya and melanie cook of nist ryan meeuf, of the software engineering institute, carnegie mellon university. Identifying potential threats to a system, cyber or otherwise, is increasingly important in todays environment. Data centric system threat modeling is threat modeling that is 160. The twelve threat modeling methods discussed in this paper come from a variety of sources and target different parts of the process. In addition to being a requirement for dod acquisition, cyber threat modeling is of great interest to other federal programs, including the department of homeland security and nasa. Its available as a free download from the microsoft download center. A process for anticipating cyber attacks threat modeling definition threat modeling is a structured process through which it pros can identify potential security threats and vulnerabilities, quantify the seriousness of each, and prioritize techniques to mitigate attack and protect it. Murugiah souppaya nist, karen scarfone scarfone cybersecurity announcement. Microsoft threat modeling tool the microsoft threat modeling tool makes threat modeling easier for all developers through a standard notation for visualizing system components, data flows, and security boundaries.
Identify and characterize the system and data of interest identify and select the attack vectors to be included in the model. This post was coauthored by nancy mead cyber threat modeling, the creation of an abstraction of a system to identify possible threats, is a required activity for dod acquisition. Numerous threat modeling methodologies are available for implementation. The 12 threatmodeling methods summarized in this post come from a variety of sources and target different parts of the process. Typically, threat modeling has been implemented using one of four approaches independently, asset centric, attacker centric, and software centric. Threat modeling is a type of risk analysis used to identify security defects in the design phase of an information system. Software centric threat modeling, also referred to as system centric, design centric, or architecture centric, begins with the design model of the system under consideration. Threat modeling definition threat modeling is a structured process through which it pros can identify potential security threats and vulnerabilities, quantify the seriousness of. Draft sp 800154 provides information on the basics of datacentric system threat modeling so that organizations can use it as part of their risk management. Chapter 3 focuses on existing threat modeling approaches, and chapter 4 discusses integrating threat modeling within the different types of software development lifecycles sdlcs. Threat modeling microsoft professional swiderski, frank, snyder, window on.
Many nist cybersecurity publications, other than the ones noted. Security risks were analyzed based on the combined effects of the likelihood of a successful attack and the impact on the identified critical components of the smart grid ics. Dec 16, 2015 in this context, a tool to perform systematic analysis of threat modeling for cps is proposed. No one threat modeling method is recommended over another. Download microsoft threat modeling tool 2016 from official. Discussion of challenges and ways of improving cyber situational awareness dominated previous chaptersin this book. This paper presents a quantitative, integrated threat modeling approach that merges software and attack centric threat modeling techniques. The outcome of the workshop will help the national institute of standards and technology nist develop a national cybersecurity center of excellence nccoe demonstration project that may be divided into multiple phases to support the full life cycle of managing information security at the data level and demonstrating compliance. Guide to datacentric system threat modeling nist computer. When cyber threat modeling is applied to systems being developed it can reduce fielded vulnerabilities and costly late rework. Pasta use case risk centric threat modeling wiley online. National institute of standards and technology has its own datacentric threat modeling methodology, which consists of four steps. Evaluation of threat modeling methodologies a case study selin juuso masters thesis may 2019 school of technology information and communication technology.
Nist sp 800154 draft guide to datacentric system threat modeling 1 152 executive summary 153 threat modeling is a form of risk assessment that models aspects of the attack and defense sides of a 154 particular logical entity, such as a piece of data, an application, a host, a system, or an environment. It is a software security requirements management platform that includes automated threat modeling capabilities. The process for attack simulation and threat analysis p. Process for attack simulation and threat analysis ucedavelez, tony, morana, marco m. There is a timing element to threat modeling that we highly recommend understanding. Almost all software systems today face a variety of threats, and the. Information protection and datacentric security management. No matter how late in the development process threat modeling is performed, it is always critical to understand weaknesses in a designs defenses. May 17, 2015 how to improve your risk assessments with attackercentric threat modeling abstract. This latest release simplifies working with threats and provides a new editor for defining your own threats. Guide to data centric system threat modeling nist sp 800154. Botnets continue to be one of the most severe security threats plaguing the internet. Nvd control sa8 security engineering principles nist.
In this blog post, i summarize 12 available threat modeling methods. Characterize the security controls for mitigating the. Analysis of the requirements model yields a threat model from which threats are identified and assigned risk values. This model reduces complexity and provides visibility, continuous control, and advanced threat. Risk centric has the objective of mitigating what matters evidence based threat modeling harvest threat intel to support threat motives leverage threat data to support prior threat patterns risk based approach focuses a lot on probability of attacks, threat likelihood, inherent risk, impact of compromise. This broad definition may just sound like the job description of a cybersecurity professional, but the important thing about a. Identify and select the attack vectors to be included in the model. Iriusrisk automated threat modeling and risk management. Threat modeling for cloud data center infrastructures nist. And there are also many ways to describe the performance operations needed to deliver those services. Regardless, this is a defining approach step that will impact assessment, gap analysis and remediation steps across the remainder of the program activities.
Dec 03, 2018 attacks can disable systems entirely or lead to the leaking of sensitive information, which would diminish consumer trust in the system provider. Pdf towards a systematic threat modeling approach for cyber. We performed a software centric threat analysis of the smart grid ics, i. Countermeasures are included in the form of actionable tasks for developers. A short questionnaire about the technical details and compliance drivers of the application is conducted to generate a set of threats. That is, cyber threat modeling can enable technology profiling, both to characterize existing technologies and to identify research gaps. Towards a systematic threat modeling approach for cyberphysical. Typically, threat modeling has been implemented using one of four approaches independently, assetcentric, attackercentric, and softwarecentric. In this paper, we conduct comprehensive threat modeling exercises based on two representative cloud infrastructures using several popular threat modeling methods, including attack surface, attack trees, attack graphs, and security metrics. Addressing critical infrastructure cyber threats for state.
A practical approach to threat modeling for digital. Software and attack centric integrated threat modeling for. Govcar, and other frameworks, tools and concepts related to threat modeling and analysis. Dec 29, 2016 in this paper, we conduct comprehensive threat modeling exercises based on two representative cloud infrastructures using several popular threat modeling methods, including attack surface, attack trees, attack graphs, and security metrics based on attack trees and attack graphs, respectively.
412 8 1102 962 1360 465 1031 701 819 1318 1358 883 117 655 695 342 1513 297 1502 852 633 565 1478 56 1451 622 725 448